DNA study makes the case that Arabian Sea humpback whales are a fourth subspecies
Mitochondrial DNA from 2,285 humpbacks shows the whales that live year-round off Oman split from other populations 43,000 to 113,000 years ago. A taxonomy committee still has to decide on the proposed subspecies.

The humpback whales that live year-round in the Arabian Sea have been evolving on their own for tens of thousands of years and should be recognized as a fourth subspecies, according to a genetic study led by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) with the Environment Society of Oman and Oman's Environment Authority. The researchers compared mitochondrial DNA from 2,285 humpbacks sampled around the world.
The study was published on 29 September in Frontiers in Marine Science. Whether the subspecies becomes official is not up to the authors: formal recognition rests with the Society for Marine Mammalogy's Taxonomy Committee.
These humpbacks feed and breed in the same tropical waters
Most humpbacks travel thousands of miles a year between cold feeding grounds and warm breeding grounds. The Arabian Sea whales stay put. They remain in the Arabian Sea all year and follow a Northern Hemisphere breeding cycle, even though there is no realistic route to northern feeding grounds.
Food comes to them instead. The southwest monsoon drives strong seasonal upwelling of deep, nutrient-rich water, which creates conditions more typical of temperate seas and lets the whales feed at tropical latitudes, the paper says. Earlier stomach-content studies found they rely more on sardines than on krill, and measurements of 238 whales examined in the 1960s showed they were larger on average than Southern Hemisphere humpbacks.
Lineages that split off 43,000 to 113,000 years ago
The genetic comparison found high differentiation between the Arabian Sea whales and the three recognized subspecies of the North Atlantic, North Pacific and Southern Hemisphere, which points to very little gene flow. The Arabian Sea population also had the lowest genetic diversity of any ocean region in the study.
The team estimated that different Arabian Sea lineages diverged between about 43,000 and 113,000 years ago, during the late Pleistocene. Their song points the same way. Recordings show a song shared between Oman and India but not with humpbacks of the southern Indian Ocean.
“The results clearly indicate the Arabian humpback whales have followed their own evolutionary trajectory for tens of thousands of years and support their recognition as a distinct subspecies.” — Dr. Rita Amaral, lead author, Wildlife Conservation Society
The researchers also sampled a skull in the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle in Paris, from a whale collected near Basra, Iraq, and described as Megaptera indica in 1883. It turned out to be a humpback closely related to today's Arabian Sea whales, which is why the proposed name is Megaptera novaeangliae indica.
A small population that has not grown in 20 years
Isolation also makes the whales vulnerable. The population is already listed as Endangered on the IUCN Red List and under the US Endangered Species Act. According to the study, it is small and shows no sign of increasing over the past two decades, and it faces a risk of extirpation without better management of known threats.
Those threats are concrete. More than two-thirds of the whales examined off Oman carried scars consistent with fishing-gear entanglement, the paper says, citing earlier work. Oman, Iran and Pakistan run large tuna fleets that use big-mesh gillnets, and container traffic in the northern Indian Ocean grew by 5% a year between 2009 and 2018. Shifts in the monsoon could also cut the supply of sardines. Ships also bring underwater noise, and the first hearing tests on Australian sea lions and fur seals show how such sounds may reach marine mammals.
Aida Al Jabri of Oman's Environment Authority said the research is "helping us move from scientific understanding towards practical conservation action." She named regional cooperation through the International Whaling Commission, which already recommends a conservation management plan for the population, and Oman's work toward protecting key habitat as a Particularly Sensitive Sea Area under the International Maritime Organization.
Sources
- Wildlife Conservation Society · newsroom.wcs.org
- frontiersin.org
How we choose and verify sources: editorial policy.











