Real stories. Real impact. A better world.
GOOD NEWS DAILY
AllAnimalsCommunityEconomyEnvironmentHealthHumanityInnovationScienceWeekly Recap

A forgotten 1980s logging experiment shows thinned mountain ash forests grew bigger trees and regained their carbon

Thirty years after a Victorian logging trial was abandoned, University of Melbourne researchers found heavily thinned mountain ash stands had grown trees 20% wider than untouched forest and had recovered all the carbon removed.

By , Editor

· Australia · 3 min read

Source: University of Melbourne ↗
Share
A dirt track winding through tall eucalyptus forest in the Australian bush
A dirt track winding through tall eucalyptus forest in the Australian bush. Photo: pen_ash (Pixabay)

Mountain ash stands in Victoria, Australia, that were heavily thinned in the late 1980s now hold trees 20% wider than the largest in nearby unharvested forest, and they have stored as much or more carbon in their wood, University of Melbourne forest scientists reported. The researchers, Kaitlyn Hammond, Craig Nitschke, Raphaël Trouvé and Patrick Baker, described the results in The Conversation.

Their peer-reviewed study, "Alternative Silvicultural Systems Maintain Multiple Values in Tall Eucalypt Forest," was published in Forest Science on 1 July.

A A$26 million trial was set up, then left to grow

In the mid-1980s, Victoria's government restructured its timber industry and invested the equivalent of A$26 million today in testing alternatives to clearfelling, the practice of cutting every tree in a block. The Silvicultural Systems Project was established between 1987 and 1989 at two sites: Tanjil Bren in the Central Highlands and Cabbage Tree Creek in East Gippsland.

It compared traditional clearfells 250 to 350 meters wide, small patch clearfells of 50 to 140 meters, and heavy thinnings in which 50% to 70% of trees were cut, with unharvested forest kept as a benchmark. At Tanjil Bren the forest was dense regrowth from the 1939 fires. By the early 2000s the early results were clear: mountain ash regenerated best on clearfelled sites. The findings were published, and then the project was largely forgotten: the access road grew over and the project sign collapsed.

Thinned stands won back the harvested carbon in 30 years

In 2014 the team took students to Tanjil Bren for a course on native forest silviculture. The clearfelled areas had regrown as expected. The surprise was in the thinned stands. The remaining trees were only about 80 years old, but the largest averaged well over a meter in diameter at chest height, and some passed 1.5 meters.

Within 30 years, the heavily thinned forest had recovered all the carbon removed in harvesting and gained as much additional carbon as the unharvested controls did over the same period, the researchers wrote. The paper, based on 53 plots across seven treatments, found the stands where 30% or 50% of the canopy was retained had the largest trees and the greatest basal area of any treatment.

Leadbeater's possums turned up only in treated plots

Bigger trees are more likely to survive fire and to form hollows, a declining habitat for rare animals such as the greater glider and Leadbeater's possum, which the paper describes as critically endangered. The possum also needs a dense understory of acacia, which sprouts only after disturbance. In the unharvested controls the amount of acacia has fallen to zero, the paper says, while every treated site regrew it.

Camera traps found Leadbeater's possums in every silvicultural treatment plot the team surveyed and in none of the unharvested areas. Another forest marsupial is better understood now too: DNA from droppings showed greater gliders eat at least 17 plant species.

“While thinning cannot (and should not) be done everywhere, it may be a useful tool to create more variety in tree ages and sizes, particularly in forests impacted by clearfelling or high-severity fire.” — Kaitlyn Hammond, Craig Nitschke, Raphaël Trouvé and Patrick Baker, University of Melbourne

The findings come from one forest type and mostly from a single site, and the authors say no one silvicultural system suits every forest. Commercial timber harvesting in Victoria's native state forests ended on 1 January 2024. The authors argue thinning can still supply wood for local industry while storing carbon and improving habitat. The researchers call for other forgotten long-term experiments in Australia's forests to be found and studied before they are lost.

Sources

How we choose and verify sources: editorial policy.

More stories: Good news for biodiversity (38) →

Your weekly dose of good news

The 5 biggest positive stories of the week, straight to your inbox. Free, no noise.