Real stories. Real impact. A better world.
GOOD NEWS DAILY
AllAnimalsCommunityEconomyEnvironmentHealthHumanityInnovationScienceWeekly Recap

Animals may have evolved up to 200 million years before their first fossils, Oxford-led study suggests

Well-preserved microfossils from Mongolia contain no animals even though animals already existed then, an Oxford-led team reports. Their molecular clock analysis puts the origin of animals between 800 and 700 million years ago.

By , Editor

· United Kingdom · 3 min read

Source: University of Oxford ↗
Share
Fossilized marine animals preserved in stone
Fossilized marine animals preserved in stone. Photo: PublicDomainPictures (Pixabay)

The first animals may have appeared between 800 and 700 million years ago, up to 200 million years before their earliest known fossils, according to a study led by the University of Oxford. The paper, "Re-evaluating molecular clock maximum age calibrations revives pre-Ediacaran divergence estimates for animals," was published in Science Advances on 2 October.

The oldest known animal fossils are about 574 million years old, Yale University wrote in its own account of the study. The team included researchers from Oxford, the University of California, Berkeley, ETH Zürich and Yale.

A Chinese fossil site had been used to cap the age of animals

The argument turns on the Weng'an Biota, a roughly 590-million-year-old deposit in South China that preserves microscopic organisms in extraordinary detail. None of them is a definite animal. Scientists had reasoned that if animals existed at the time, Weng'an would have preserved them, so animals must have originated later. Recent molecular clock studies used that logic to set a maximum age for animal origins.

The Oxford team tested the reasoning on the Kheseen Biota in Mongolia, which is about 550 million years old and shares some species with Weng'an. By then, animal fossils are known from other places, including Namibia and South China. The researchers examined more than 140 samples under a scanning electron microscope and found new microfossil species, including spiny acritarchs and embryo-like fossils with internal cells. None could be confidently identified as an animal.

“The Kheseen microfossils are just as well-preserved, yet animals continue to be absent – despite the fact we know at that point they existed.” — Ross Anderson, associate professor, Museum of Natural History, University of Oxford, senior author

Animals living in other environments, or chemistry that failed to preserve soft remains, could explain the gap, the researchers wrote. If Kheseen can miss animals that were alive, they argue, Weng'an's lack of animals proves nothing about whether they existed 590 million years ago.

Older rocks used as a ceiling push the estimate back

Instead, the team used three older deposits, about 850 to 730 million years old, as the upper limit: the Svanbergfjellet Formation in Norway, the Bitter Springs Group in Australia and the Chuar Group in Arizona. A molecular clock compares genetic differences between living species and works backwards, using fossil dates as reference points, to estimate when lineages split. With the older limits, the estimated origin of animals moved back by about 200 million years.

Other evidence hints at a hidden early history. Chemical traces in ancient rocks are consistent with sponges living at least 650 million years ago, according to the Oxford statement. An origin between 800 and 700 million years ago would also mean animals arose before or during the Cryogenian "Snowball Earth" glaciations, which began about 720 million years ago.

No animal fossil from that window has been found

The authors are clear that this is an estimate. First author Orin Lole Durbin, an Oxford undergraduate at the time of the study and now a PhD student at Virginia Tech, said: "Pre-Ediacaran animal body fossils still elude us, and this analysis does not prove that animals existed 800 million years ago." Early animals were probably small and soft-bodied, without shells or bones.

Some of the same scientists set an earlier boundary. In a 2023 review led by Anderson, with Yale paleontologist Derek Briggs as senior author, the team looked at 789-million-year-old and older rocks suited to preserving soft tissue and found no animals there. "Such considerations suggest that animals were not present earlier than 790 million years ago," Briggs said then, according to Yale News. Most of the new 800-to-700-million-year window falls below that limit. Fossils keep filling gaps in other lineages too; in Egypt, an ancient crocodile species was identified in rock from near the Great Sphinx.

Briggs, a co-author of the new paper, said "future discoveries are needed to refine our knowledge of the nature and timing of the earliest animal life on the planet." The Oxford researchers say future work should search fossil deposits from different environments and weigh body fossils, traces and chemical biomarkers together.

Sources

How we choose and verify sources: editorial policy.

Your weekly dose of good news

The 5 biggest positive stories of the week, straight to your inbox. Free, no noise.